Crandall 2008 WL 5459850 (Bankr.S.D.Tex.)

Circumstantial evidence supported default judgment on credit card issuer's nondischargeability claim.

A combination of facts found in a Chapter 7 debtor's schedules and statement of financial affairs provided adequate circumstantial evidence to support the conclusion, for the purposes of a default judgment on the credit card issuer's claim that the credit card debt fell within the fraud discharge exception, that, at the time he incurred the credit card charge, the debtor intended not to pay the charge but to file a bankruptcy petition instead. These facts included the debtor's divorce, the timing of the debtor's prepetition $8,007 charge to credit card, the identity of the party to whom the charge was made, the debtor's payments in the 90 days preceding his bankruptcy, the proximity of the payment and the filing of bankruptcy, and the debtor's hopeless financial circumstances. Although the evidence might not be sufficient in other circumstances, the court emphasized, it was enough for a default judgment.